Truth Project
Justice scales and books

Can a Judge Fairly Decide a Case When He May Be a Witness?

The pending recusal matter asks whether Judge Scott D. Larson may remain the decision-maker when court filings and record materials raise issues of personal knowledge, disputed communications, and potential witness testimony.

This matter concerns Thomas v. Traeger, Adams County, Illinois, Case No. 2013-F-62. The concern is whether Judge Larson may have personal knowledge of disputed events and may be a material witness, while still being asked to decide matters connected to those events.

A fair proceeding should allow relevant witnesses and evidence to be considered under equal rules for both sides. The purpose of the pending motion is to seek a neutral decision-maker and a full, fair opportunity to present the record.

Attorneys and Court

Explore Our Commitment to Justice and Legal Excellence

Delve into the core principles that define our dedication to upholding justice and supporting legal professionals, outlining the vision that shapes our approach and services.

Navigate the Legal Landscape with Confidence

Discover the pivotal roles attorneys and court professionals play, and gain insight into how engaging with this knowledge can empower your legal understanding and decisions.

Explore the Roles of Attorneys and Court Actors

Gain in-depth perspectives on the functions and interactions of legal professionals within the judicial system.

Attorney Roles

Understand the responsibilities and duties that define an attorney’s role in court proceedings.

Court Participants

Discover how judges, jurors, and clerks contribute to the administration of justice.

Legal Processes

Examine key legal procedures and their impact on case outcomes.