Truth Project
Justice scales and books

Can a Judge Fairly Decide a Case When He May Be a Witness?

The pending recusal matter asks whether Judge Scott D. Larson may remain the decision-maker when court filings and record materials raise issues of personal knowledge, disputed communications, and potential witness testimony.

This matter concerns Thomas v. Traeger, Adams County, Illinois, Case No. 2013-F-62. The concern is whether Judge Larson may have personal knowledge of disputed events and may be a material witness, while still being asked to decide matters connected to those events.

A fair proceeding should allow relevant witnesses and evidence to be considered under equal rules for both sides. The purpose of the pending motion is to seek a neutral decision-maker and a full, fair opportunity to present the record.

Contact

Reach out to us anytime with your questions, feedback, or inquiries about our blog and its topics.

188 Hood Avenue, Suite 202

302 Maple Street, Office 5

+1-800-555-1234

contact@ourblog.com

Reach Out and Connect With Us Now

Have questions or feedback? Use this page to contact us directly for any inquiries related to our blog content, and we’ll respond promptly.